GDDR5 vs GDDR5X vs HBM vs HBM2 Memory Comparison

Graphics Cards are equipped with the latest and the fastest memories around. The most popular and commonly used high performance memory in budget-range, mid-range and most of the high-end graphics card is GDDR5 memory. GDDR5 has been around for quite some time and is used on many high performance graphics cards. But the time is moving forward and technology is getting more and more advanced and now we can see faster memories being developed that includes GDDR5X, HBM and HBM2 memory. Here in this post i am going to tell you about all these high performance graphics card memories and also compare them on basis of physical and technical aspects.

Check out: Best Budget Gaming DDR4 RAM for Intel & AMD PC

GDDR5 Memory

GDDR5 is the most widely used high-speed memory that you see in the current generation graphics cards. It is the successor of GDDR3 and GDDR4 memory. Nowadays GDDR3 or DDR3 is only used in entry level graphics cards whereas GDDR4 is not even in existence anymore.

GDDR5 is one of the fastest graphics card memories and is used in many graphics cards starting from budget, midrange to high-end graphics cards. Some of the latest powerful graphics cards using GDDR5 memory are GTX 1060, GTX 1070 and Radeon RX 480. Budget and mid-range graphics cards using GDDR5 memory are GT 730, GT 740, RX 460, GTX 750 Ti, GTX 1050 Ti etc.

memory

GDDR5 is a high bandwidth memory and has lower power consumption compared to its predecessors. It can reach speeds or has transfer rates to up to 8 Gbps. GDDR5 memory is manufactured by Samsung, Hynix, ELPIDA or Micron, and GDDR5 memory chips are available in sizes of  512MB, 1GB, 2GB, 4GB and 8GB. The bus-width of each GDDR5 memory chip is 32-bits wide. The so called successor of GDDR5 memory is GDDR5X memory which is even faster.

GDDR5X Memory

GDDR5X is an upgrade or improved version of the GDDR5 memory. Both GDDR5 and GDDR5X are high bandwidth SGRAM (synchronous graphics random access memory) that are used in graphics cards, high performance servers and other advanced hardware units. GDDR5X is twice as fast as the normal GDDR5 memory and can achieve speeds in range of 10 – 14 Gbps. In future the memory speed of 16 Gbps can be made possible for GDDR5X. Currently GDDR5X memory is manufactured by Micron.

GDDR5X is also consumes less power compared to GDDR5. GDDR5X memory chips are available in sizes of 4GB, 6GB, 8GB and 16GB. The most popular Graphics Cards using GDDR5X memory includes GeForce GTX 1080 and Nvidia TITAN X (Pascal). High-end Workstation Graphics Cards such as Nvidia Quadro P5000 and Quadro P6000 also uses high speed GDDR5X memory. Samsung is planning to launch GDDR6 memory in 2018 which will be the real successor of GDDR5 memory. It will have speeds up to 16 Gbps and have lower power consumption.

Note: It must be noted that in a PCB you cannot replace GDDR5 with GDDR5X memory because both have different pins. GDDR5 uses 170 pins per chip while GDDR5X uses 190 pins per chip.

HBM Memory

HBM stands for High Bandwidth Memory that is manufactured by Hynix and Samsung. It is also used in graphics cards and other advanced units. HBM memory is used in few graphics cards as of now. HBM is non-planar memory with 3D design structure in form of a cube or cuboid. In HBM multiple memory chips are stacked over one another to form a cube like structure. This makes it occupies less space on the graphics card PCB and you can even put it close to the GPU. The change in the surface area also allows faster processing along the chip.

 

gddr5-vs-hbm-form-factor

 

HBM memory placed closed to the GPU in a graphics card PCB as shown below.

hbm

Each Stack of HBM memory is independent of the other stacks but they work together. HBM is also known as compact memory or stacked memory because of its small form factor. A normal HBM memory stack consist of four 4 DRAM dies on a base die and has two 128-bit channels per DRAM die making 8 channels in total which results in 1024-bit per stack of memory interface. So a graphics card having four 4-Hi HBM stacks have memory bus width of 4 x 1024 = 4096-bits. The operating speed of HBM memory is 1 Gbps but its memory bandwidth is much higher compared to GDDR5 memory. This is because of its much wider memory bus. The memory bandwidth of HBM memory can go as high as 128 GB/s per stack. HBM can have 1 GB capacity per stack and supports 4GB per package.

hbm-vs-gddr5

HBM memory uses less power compared to both GDDR5 and GDDR5X memory. The first graphics card to use HBM memory was AMD Radeon R9 Fury X. It is also used in dual GPU graphics card Radeon Pro Duo.

Advantages of HBM Memory

  • Lower Power Consumption
  • Small Form Factor
  • Higher Bandwidth
  • Less heating
  • Better Perforamce

Disadvantages of HBM Memory

  • Expensive as of now
  • Low availability as of now

HBM2 Memory

HBM 2 is the second generation HBM memory having all HBM characteristics but with higher memory speed and bandwidth. It can have 8 DRAM dies per stack and with transfer rates up to 2 Gbps. With 1024-bit wide memory interface it can have memory bandwidth of 256 GB/s per stack which is double of normal HBM or HBM 1 memory. The total capacity of HBM2 is also more and it can have up to 8GB per stack. The first GPU chip to utilize HBM2 memory is Nvidia Tesla P100. Nvidia’s latest Pascal series Workstation Graphics Card Nvidia Quadro GP100 also comes with HBM2 memory. HBM2 memory will be used mainly for VR Gaming, AR Gaming and other heavy memory intensive applications. The successor of HBM2 is HBM3 which will be launched in 2019 or 2020.

How to Calculate Memory Bandwidth

Use the below mentioned formula to calculate bandwidth of any type of memory.

Memory Bandwidth = (Effective Memory Clock x Bus Width) / 8

GDDR5 vs GDDR5X vs HBM vs HBM2 Memory

Here is neck to neck comparison of GDDR5, GDDR5X, HBM and HBM2 memory types.

Memory GDDR5 GDDR5X HBM HBM2
Manufacturer Samsung, Hynix, Elpida Micron Hynix, Samsung Samsung, Hynix
Appearance Square / Rectangular Chip Square / Rectangular Chip Cube / Cuboid Cube / Cuboid
Maximum Capacity 8GB per chip 16GB per chip 1GB per Stack 4GB / 8GB per Stack
Maximum Speed 8 Gbps 10 to 14 Gbps (16 Gbps in future) 1 Gbps 2 Gbps
Bus Width 32-bit per chip 64-bit per chip 1024-bit per stack 1024-bit per stack or more
Power Consumption Low Same / Lower than GDDR5X Lower than GDDR5 and GDDR5X Lower than HBM
Graphics Cards Used in Many Graphics Cards from budget, midrange to high-end e.g. GT 740, GTX 1070, RX 480 etc. GeForce GTX 1080, Nvidia Titan X (Pascal) Radeon R9 Fury X, Radeon Pro Duo Nvidia Tesla P100, Nvidia Quadro GP100

Final Words

At the end I would like to say that all these above mentioned memories are made for high performance and are used in high performance hardware including top graphics cards. GDDR5 is the oldest of the lot while others are relatively newer. HBM2 is certainty the best memory in terms of performance and power consumption but it is very new and is not used in any commercial graphics cards as of now. You can expect to see HBM2 memory in the upcoming high-end graphics cards from Nvidia and AMD in 2017. If you have any queries or suggestions then you can connect with me by leaving a comment below.

Leave a Reply